From J. D. Hooker [2 October 1871]1
Kew
Monday
Dear Darwin
I return Huxley’s article which I have read with all the admiration I can express.2 What a wonderful Essayist he is & incomparable critic & defender of the faithful. Well, I think you are avenged of your Enemy:—but are not happier for that— though you must be for the spirit & body which the avenger has given to the subject, & above all for the grand use he has made of your own argument for confuting your enemy. What you must feel, & always feel, is, that peculiar & quite unreasonable bitter sorrowing which a man excites who praises you to your face & abuses you behind your back.—3 Why should this excite anything but contempt at worst, or pity at best? & yet there is no man with generous emotions but feels more sad & sorry over such treatment than either angry or vindictive.
The Psychological passages seem to me to be wonderfully clear & good, how tight he clothes a difficult idea in language. I was particularly struck with the paragraphs on Neurosis & Psychosis.—consciousness & its physical basis4—but really it is difficult to single out either passages or subjects, all is so good & there is so much power & acumen in the treatment of every branch of his subject— you may call it an essay, a critique—an exposition—or discussion—an enquiry—or what else you will— you may read for one & all of these aims.
The Exposition of Mivart’s presumptuous ignorance in citing the Catholic fathers is delicious—that’s the last pitfall the poor devil expected to be snared into.5
The tumbling over Wallace is however if not an equal feat, a far far greater service to Science.6
The appeal to conscience in the matter of the clergy & the 6 days is very powerful, & must make many a poor Devil wince in the pulpit.7 And the quiet contempt with which he treats the Squires & Parsons is extraordinarily humorous in it’s manner.8
Well, the article has been a God-send to me, for I am very very low—& cannot get my spirits up—about my poor Mother’s state. I have just returned from Torquay.9 I am also in the most detestable position that a scientific man, or an officer, or a gentleman, can be with my Lord & Master Ayrton, who I have officially denounced to the 1st. Lord of the Treasury for his conduct to me & to Kew: & I need not say that our lives are not the happiest after such an Explosion!10 How it will all end God knows, I began the battle with heart & spirit—& gloried in it— but my Mother’s condition has poisoned the whole, & I also left my sister very ill, even for her—11 so I am in the state of utter disquiet: not caring a farthing what the Treasury or Ayrton do— What a poor lot we men are— a woman would be twice as rational as I am, under twice the hard lines.
God Bless you dear old friend | Yrs affect | J D Hooker
Footnotes
Bibliography
Abich, Otto Hermann Wilhelm. 1841. Geologische Betrachtungen über die vulkanischen Erscheinungen und Bildungen in Unter- und Mittel-Italien. Braunschweig.
Allan, Mea. 1967. The Hookers of Kew, 1785–1911. London: Michael Joseph.
Descent: The descent of man, and selection in relation to sex. By Charles Darwin. 2 vols. London: John Murray. 1871.
Huxley, Leonard, ed. 1918. Life and letters of Sir Joseph Dalton Hooker, OM, GCSI. Based on materials collected and arranged by Lady Hooker. 2 vols. London: John Murray.
Huxley, Thomas Henry. 1871b. Mr. Darwin’s critics. Contemporary Review 18: 443–76.
MacLeod, Roy M. 1974. The Ayrton incident: a commentary on the relations of science and government in England, 1870–1873. In Science and values: patterns of tradition and change, edited by Arnold Thackray and Everett Mendelsohn. New York: Humanities Press.
Mivart, St George Jackson. 1871a. On the genesis of species. London: Macmillan and Co.
Summary
On Huxley’s article for Contemporary Review [see 7977] confuting Mivart. It has cheered him,
for he is very low about his mother’s state.
Is also in detestable position with "my lord and master", A. S. Ayrton. JDH has denounced him to the [First] Lord of the Treasury [W. E. Gladstone] for his conduct.
Letter details
- Letter no.
- DCP-LETT-7981
- From
- Joseph Dalton Hooker
- To
- Charles Robert Darwin
- Sent from
- Kew
- Source of text
- DAR 103: 80–2
- Physical description
- ALS 5pp
Please cite as
Darwin Correspondence Project, “Letter no. 7981,” accessed on 17 May 2024, https://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/letter/?docId=letters/DCP-LETT-7981.xml
Also published in The Correspondence of Charles Darwin, vol. 19