skip to content

Darwin Correspondence Project

From Alexander Agassiz   16 April 1881

Tortugas

April 16, 1881.

It is very natural you should be in my mind, as I am in the midst of corals. I came down here about six weeks ago to study the surface fauna of the Gulf Stream. The Coast Survey placed a small launch at my disposal to go out and scour the surface when the weather is favorable. Unfortunately thus far I have had little chance to accomplish what I started to do, as I find is nearly always the case on the seashore— you never can do what you wish, but have to be satisfied with what turns up. Thus far I have only found the more common things with which I was familiar from my former Blake experience and from meeting them late in the fall at Newport.1

I took advantage of bad weather to finish up a lot of drawings and notes on Velella and Porpita, and have some interesting things about the post-embryonic stages of both, which I hope to publish next summer if I get time to finish the drawings.2 The greater part of my time I spend in running round inside the reef in the launch and getting at the distribution of the different genera of corals. The number of species here is not great, so it makes their mapping out a simple matter. The Tortugas being the very last of the Florida reefs I find much that has not been noticed before and helps to explain, somewhat differently from what was done by Father, the formation of the reefs.3 On my way here I went across the northern base of the Peninsula of Florida—from Jacksonville to Cedar Keys, and found halfway across a series of hammocks and old coral reefs, such as are found in the Everglades at the southern extremity. In tracing the growth of the reefs and the formation of the Peninsula, I have come across no signs of any elevation. Everything, on the contrary, tends to show that the immense plateau which forms the base upon which the Peninsula of Florida is formed, was built up by the débris of animal remains,— Mollusks, Corals, Echinoderms, etc. (after it had originally reached a certain depth in the ocean), until it reached the proper height for corals to flourish. This here is not much deeper than seven to eight fathoms; generally six fathoms marks the limit. To the westward of this group of reefs is a coral reef starting on a bank at a depth of seven fathoms.

I expect to publish a small map of the distribution of the corals of the Tortugas as soon as I return home, in my report of work (not done) to the Superintendent of the Coast Survey. I shall, however, have first to finish reading the proofs of the Challenger Echini, the last pages of which I expect to find awaiting my return home, and I trust you will see that Memoir out during the summer.4

Footnotes

For Agassiz’s dredging missions aboard the US coast survey steamer Blake, see A. Agassiz 1888. During his 1881 visit to the Tortugas, Agassiz also further developed his theory of coral reef formation; in opposition to CD’s deductive subsidence theory, he argued from empirical evidence that coral reefs began to grow on banks that were rising not because of elevation but through the accumulation of animal remains (mainly plankton) on mudbanks (Dobbs 2005). Agassiz had established a laboratory at Newport, Rhode Island, in 1877 (G. R. Agassiz ed. 1913, pp. 153–4).
Velella and Porpita are genera in the hydrozoan family Porpitidae. Agassiz published a study of the species found in the region in A. Agassiz 1883; he included twelve plates, figuring the morphology and anatomy of specimens at various stages of development.
Alexander Agassiz argued that the accumulation (through the action of waves and winds) of the remains of pelagic creatures on parts of the seabed provided areas at the right depths for corals to grow and reefs to develop. In contrast, his father, Louis Agassiz, had believed that reefs must have been formed by shifts in the relative levels of land and sea; on this view, no new reefs were likely to form in the deep water off the coast of Florida because these relative levels were no longer changing. Extracts from Louis Agassiz’s report on the topography of Florida, including coral reefs, were published in 1851, but did not appear in full until Alexander published them in 1880 (L. Agassiz 1851; L. Agassiz 1880). Alexander Agassiz’s own results were published in A. Agassiz 1882.
No map appeared with Agassiz’s report to the superintendent (A. Agassiz 1881a) but several were included in his article on the Tortugas and Florida reefs (A. Agassiz 1882). Agassiz’s report on the Echinoidea (the class of heart urchins, sand dollars, and sea urchins) collected during the Challenger expedition was published in 1881 (A. Agassiz 1881b). There is a copy of this report in the Darwin Library–Down.

Bibliography

Agassiz, Alexander. 1881a. (Letter No. 5.) — To Carlile P. Patterson, superintendent United States Coast and Geodetic Survey, from Alexander Agassiz, on the explorations in the vicinity of the Tortugas, during March and April, 1881. Bulletin of the Museum of Comparative Zoology at Harvard College 9 (1881–2): 145–9.

Agassiz, Alexander. 1881b. Report on the Echinoidea dredged by H.M.S. Challenger, during the years 1873–1876. Report on the scientific results of the voyage of the H.M.S. Challenger during the years 1873–76. Zoology. Vol. 3, part 9. London: Her Majesty’s Stationery Office.

Agassiz, Alexander. 1882. Explorations of the surface fauna of the Gulf Stream, under the auspices of the United States Coast Survey: II. The Tortugas and Florida Reefs. [Read 15 November 1882.] Memoirs of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences n.s. 11 (1885): 107–33.

Agassiz, Alexander. 1883. Exploration of the surface fauna of the Gulf Stream: under the auspices of the Coast Survey. [Report] 3, part 1, The Porpitidæ and Velellidæ. Memoirs of the Museum of Comparative Zoology at Harvard College 8: no. 2.

Agassiz, Alexander. 1888. Three cruises of the United States Coast and Geodetic Survey Steamer ‘Blake’ in the Gulf of Mexico, in the Caribbean Sea, and along the Atlantic coast of the United States, from 1877 to 1880. Boston and New York: Houghton, Mifflin and Company.

Agassiz, George Russell, ed. 1913. Letters and recollections of Alexander Agassiz, with a sketch of his life and work. London: Constable & Co.

Agassiz, Louis. 1851c. Extracts from the report of Professor Agassiz to the superintendent of the Coast Survey, on the examination of the Florida reefs, keys, and coast. Annual Report of the Superintendent of the Coast Survey (1851): 145–60.

Agassiz, Louis. 1880. Report on the Florida reefs. Memoirs of the Museum of Comparative Zoology at Harvard College 7: no. 1.

Dobbs, David. 2005. Reef madness: Charles Darwin, Alexander Agassiz, and the meaning of coral. New York: Pantheon Books.

Summary

Is mapping coral distribution on the Tortugas reef. His observations on the Florida peninsula suggest that it was built up from the debris of animal remains and was not elevated.

Letter details

Letter no.
DCP-LETT-13122
From
Alexander Agassiz
To
Charles Robert Darwin
Sent from
Tortugas
Source of text
G. R. Agassiz ed. 1913, pp. 281–2

Please cite as

Darwin Correspondence Project, “Letter no. 13122,” accessed on 17 May 2024, https://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/letter/?docId=letters/DCP-LETT-13122.xml

letter